In 2020, members of the U.S. Marshals Violent Crime Fugitive Task Force moved on a residence in Chester, Pennsylvania, to apprehend Jabree Robertson, who was wanted for first-degree murder. Robertson did not surrender. Court records show he remained in a standoff with officers before they entered a bedroom to take him into custody. During that arrest, Robertson sustained injuries. He attributed those injuries to excessive force by the officers involved.
Robertson filed a civil complaint against the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act, arguing that the force used against him during the arrest was unreasonable. The case moved to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
What the District Court Found
The Eastern District ruled in favor of the United States. The court found the officers' actions reasonable, basing that conclusion on two central factors: Robertson's violent criminal history and the potential threat he posed at the time of the arrest. The District Court weighed the severity of the underlying crime — a first-degree murder charge — the immediate threat assessment, and the fact that Robertson was actively resisting and refusing to surrender. Those findings formed the foundation of the lower court's judgment.
The Third Circuit's November 2026 Ruling
On November 20, 2026, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued its decision in Robertson v. United States, affirming the District Court's judgment in full. The appellate court stated it would overturn factual findings only if there was clear error. It found none.
The Third Circuit applied the established reasonableness framework in evaluating the officers' conduct. That framework directs courts to consider three factors: the severity of the crime at issue, whether the suspect posed an immediate threat to officers or others, and whether the suspect was resisting arrest or attempting to evade custody. All three factors, according to the court's analysis, supported the officers' actions.
Robertson raised arguments about the absence of evidence concerning the use of a specific device during the arrest and challenged the characterization of his injuries. The appellate court dismissed both arguments. Court records show the Third Circuit found those points insufficient to establish clear error in the District Court's factual determinations.
What the Decision Means for Federal Tort Claims Involving Use of Force
The ruling draws a clear line around the deference appellate courts extend to trial-level factual findings in FTCA cases involving police conduct. Plaintiffs who lose at the district court level on use-of-force questions face a steep climb on appeal. The clear error standard, as applied here, means factual conclusions reached after a full district court review will rarely be disturbed unless the record contains an obvious and demonstrable mistake.
The decision also reaffirms what courts expect of officers in the field. According to the ruling, officers are expected to act based on the information available to them at the time of the incident — not on facts that emerge later. That standard matters in real-time fugitive operations, where threat assessments are made quickly, with incomplete information, against suspects with documented violent histories.
The U.S. Marshals Violent Crime Fugitive Task Force operated here in exactly that environment. Robertson was wanted for first-degree murder. He refused commands. He forced a standoff. When officers entered the bedroom, the situation had already escalated through Robertson's own refusal to comply. The courts, at both levels, found that context dispositive.
For task force commanders and agency legal counsel, the case offers a concrete example of how courts evaluate force used during fugitive apprehensions. The three-factor reasonableness test — crime severity, immediate threat, and active resistance — remains the operative standard. Documentation of a suspect's criminal history, the nature of the standoff, and the sequence of events leading to physical contact will all bear directly on how a district court rules if a complaint is filed.
The FTCA provides the procedural vehicle through which plaintiffs bring excessive force claims against federal officers and the United States directly. Robertson v. United States shows that vehicle has real limits when district courts make detailed factual findings and appellate review is confined to the clear error standard. Agencies facing similar claims should expect that a well-developed district court record, grounded in officer testimony and documented threat assessments, will be difficult for plaintiffs to overturn on appeal.
