Policy & Law

Hiring Numbers Climb, But Staffing Gaps Persist Across U.S. Agencies

A May 2026 national survey by the Police Executive Research Forum found sworn staffing has returned to 2022 levels, with agencies hiring 17.6% more officers than in 2024. Yet total sworn counts remain below January 2020 figures. Departments in Seattle, Columbia, and Honolulu are cutting hiring timelines and rebuilding from the inside, while cities like Chicago and Portsmouth continue to feel the strain of deep, sustained vacancies.

Pavashot LE News Desk

A May 2026 survey by the Police Executive Research Forum, drawing on data from 197 agencies, found that sworn staffing rose 1.4% in 2025 and that agencies hired 17.6% more officers than they did in 2024. PERF described those numbers as a return to 2022 levels. That sounds like progress. It is not a recovery. Sworn staffing across respondent agencies still sits below January 2020 figures, according to the survey.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects roughly 60,100 annual openings for police and detectives through 2035. That figure reflects not just growth but constant churn — retirements, resignations, and terminations eating into headcount faster than academies can replace it. Research from California puts a number on that churn: total separations rose 11% between 2016 and 2020, then jumped more than 30% between 2020 and 2022. Average base salaries for California officers, adjusted for inflation, dropped from $116,000 in 2011 to $110,000 in 2023. Average overtime pay, meanwhile, climbed from $10,000 to over $25,000 in that same span — a sign that agencies were backfilling gaps with mandatory hours rather than headcount.

Where Agencies Are Losing Applicants

Many departments are shedding viable candidates before the process gets serious. According to the National Policing Institute, agencies lose between 50% and 70% of qualified applicants before the background check phase, largely because hiring processes move slowly and communicate poorly with candidates. NPI also identifies leadership culture as one of the strongest determinants of officer retention — meaning the problem does not end at the offer letter.

Slow timelines compound the attrition. Candidates drop out when they hear nothing for weeks. Competing employers — private security, federal agencies, neighboring departments — move faster. The result is that agencies with drawn-out processes are not just failing to hire; they are actively selecting against candidates with the most options.

Seattle, Columbia, and Honolulu Push for Speed

The Seattle Police Department cut its hiring timeline from a range of five to nine months down to three to five months. The department reported more than 100 new recruits in the first seven months of 2025 as a result.

The Columbia Police Department took a different route. Facing 49 sworn vacancies in July 2024 — a figure that represented a serious operational problem — the department launched a department-wide reorganization and stood up an in-house academy. By June 2025, sworn vacancies had dropped to five. Patrol shift staffing increased 27% in the summer of 2025 compared to the same period the previous year.

In Honolulu, Police Chief David Lazar said the department is working to close a vacancy gap that stood at 275 positions, reduced from a previous total of 400. The department is pursuing a goal to complete the full hiring process within 90 days, which Chief Lazar described as a potential record for the agency.

Chicago and Portsmouth Show the Cost of Sustained Shortfalls

Not every agency has found a turnaround story. The Chicago Police Department had 11,433 sworn officers as of September 2026. In March 2019, that number was 13,319 — a loss of roughly 1,886 officers over seven years. The department has reached preliminary compliance with 99% of its federal consent decree requirements, but monitors have warned that staffing shortages remain a central challenge to sustaining that progress.

Portsmouth tells a smaller but equally concrete story. Fourteen members left the department in the 18 months prior to October 2026. As of that month, the patrol division was operating at 25 of 37 authorized positions. Officers logged 410 mandatory order-ins during 2026 — forced holdovers to cover shifts that could not otherwise be staffed. That is not an abstract workforce problem. It is a measurable burden falling on the officers who stayed.

The California data on overtime mirrors what Portsmouth's numbers show on the ground. When agencies cannot hire fast enough, the existing workforce absorbs the gap through mandatory extra shifts. Inflation-adjusted base pay has declined. Overtime has tripled. The math is not sustainable, and it accelerates the separations that created the shortage in the first place.

The PERF survey numbers suggest the worst of the post-2020 collapse has passed. But the agencies still operating with significant vacancies — and the ones watching real wages fall while overtime climbs — have not yet closed the distance between where they are and where they were before 2020.

NPDD — Non-Pyro Diversionary Device

Documenting compliant, defensible options?

NPDD — Non-Pyro Diversionary Device

  • No pyrotechnic burn injuries to litigate
  • Six payload configurations
  • Datasheets for policy attachments

Related News

From Policy & Law